Exotic Car Rental in Buffalo, NY

  • Free cancellation on most offers
  • 24/7 customer service
  • No hidden fees
  • Pay later on many offers
Driver age
Quick filters

Optional. Narrow the search now; you can change or remove these on the results page.

Seats
Options
  • 13high-end cars
  • 5rental companies
  • from $92 per day
  • 9.2 top rated · National

The average high-end car costs $183 a day here. Most offered: Cadillac XTS, Audi A3 and Chrysler 300. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026.

  • In the terminal: 2
  • Free cancellation: 5 of 5
  • Debit card accepted: 1 of 5
  • National
  • Hertz
  • Enterprise
  • Alamo
  • Dollar
No supercar rental in Buffalo. The most exclusive cars available are Cadillac XTS, Audi A3 and Chrysler 300 from $92 a day.

Exotic car rental prices in Buffalo

Class Typical cars Suppliers From / day
Luxury Audi A4, Cadillac CTS, Cadillac XTS 4 $113
Premium Nissan Maxima, Chevrolet Impala, Audi A3 5 $92

Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026. Rental companies guarantee the car class, not the exact model. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

Chevrolet Impala rental car in Buffalo National

Chevrolet Impala

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $92/day
Nissan Maxima rental car in Buffalo Hertz

Nissan Maxima

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $100/day
Cadillac CTS rental car in Buffalo Alamo

Cadillac CTS

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 5 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $113/day
Audi A4 rental car in Buffalo Enterprise

Audi A4

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 5 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $115/day
Chrysler 300 rental car in Buffalo Hertz

Chrysler 300

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 5 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $153/day
Audi A3 rental car in Buffalo Enterprise

Audi A3

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $175/day
Cadillac XTS rental car in Buffalo National

Cadillac XTS

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 5 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $180/day

Companies with high-end cars in Buffalo

Prices and conditions come from searches on TREWL and may have changed. Ratings come from CarTrawler customer reviews, as shown in searches up to Aug 2026. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

National

In the terminal Mon–Fri 06:00–23:59 · Sat–Sun 06:00–23:00 24 min wait Credit card only 3 models
9.2
Excellent 1000+ reviews
from $92/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 9.0 Cleanliness 9.2 Service at the rental desk 9.3 Pick-up process 9.2 Drop-off process 9.4

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee
  • Breakdown assistance

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Winter tires · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

National at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee St, Buffalo, 14225, NY
8338135271

Hertz

18 min wait Credit card only 2 models
8.5
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $100/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.3 Cleanliness 8.6 Service at the rental desk 8.4 Pick-up process 8.3 Drop-off process 9.0

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Hertz in Buffalo
369 Niagara Street, Buffalo, Ny, 14201, NY
7168540283

Enterprise

21 min wait Credit card only 3 models
8.4
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $115/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.0 Cleanliness 8.4 Service at the rental desk 8.6 Pick-up process 8.3 Drop-off process 8.9

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Office

Enterprise at Buffalo 1312 Main Street
2643 Delaware Ave, Buffalo, 14216 1102, NY
7168730100

Alamo

In the terminal 10 min wait Credit card only 2 models
8.2
Excellent 5000+ reviews
from $113/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.6 Cleanliness 8.3 Service at the rental desk 8.6 Pick-up process 8.3 Drop-off process 8.4

Included in the price

  • Taxes
  • Airport fee

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Alamo at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee St, Buffalo, 14225, NY
8338135268

Dollar

Daily 06:00–23:59 15 min wait Credit and debit cards 1 model
8.2
Excellent 5000+ reviews
from $554/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.9 Cleanliness 8.5 Service at the rental desk 8.1 Pick-up process 7.9 Drop-off process 8.8

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee
  • Breakdown assistance
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Dollar at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY, United States, 14225
(866) 434-2226

Rental conditions in Buffalo

Based on 5 suppliers here and nearby. Data from the 12 months to Aug 2026.

Debit card Accepted by 1 of 5 suppliers: Dollar.
Credit card Usually required, in the main driver's name. 4 of 5 suppliers list no debit option.
Mileage Unlimited at all 5 suppliers.
Fuel policy Full to full (4 suppliers)
Transmission All cars are automatic.
Electric and hybrid Toyota Prius Hybrid, from $143 a day.
Cancellation Free up to 48 hours before pick-up at 5 suppliers.
Insurance included Theft protection (TP) (3 suppliers), Third-party liability (TPL) (3 suppliers).
Included in the price Airport fee, Breakdown assistance, Taxes
One-way rental Allowed by 1 supplier.
Extras GPS (4 suppliers), Infant seat (4 suppliers), Child seat (4 suppliers), Booster seat (4 suppliers), Ski rack (3 suppliers), Winter tires (1 supplier)
Special offers Pre-registration available (3 suppliers)

Where to pick up in Buffalo

Pick-up point Type Cars Suppliers From / day Average wait
Buffalo Airport · 13 km Airport 10 5 $113 17 min
Buffalo · 3 km City office 2 1 $100 18 min
Buffalo 1312 Main Street · 3 km City office 1 1 $115 21 min

Exotic car rental near Buffalo

Exotic car rental in the USA

Other car types in Buffalo

Exotic car rental in Buffalo: FAQ

Can I rent a Ferrari or Lamborghini in Buffalo?

Our partners in Buffalo do not list supercars. The most exclusive cars available are Cadillac XTS, Audi A3 and Chrysler 300 from $92 a day.

How much does exotic car rental cost in Buffalo?

Luxury from $113. Premium from $92. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026.

Which companies offer exotic car rental in Buffalo?

National, Hertz, Enterprise, Alamo and Dollar. Hertz is the cheapest, about $126 a day on average. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026.

Can I rent a car in Buffalo with a debit card?

1 of 5 companies accept a debit card: Dollar.

Can I return the car somewhere else in Buffalo?

11% of searches in Buffalo are one-way. Enter a different drop-off location in the search form to see the one-way fee.