Convertible Car Rental in Long Island

  • Free cancellation on most offers
  • 24/7 customer service
  • No hidden fees
  • Pay later on many offers
Driver age
Quick filters

Optional. Narrow the search now; you can change or remove these on the results page.

Seats
Options
  • 19convertibles
  • 6rental companies
  • from $100 per day
  • 9.3 top rated · National

The average convertible costs $258 a day here. Most offered: Ford Mustang Convertible, Jeep Wrangler and BMW 4 Series Convertible. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Nov 2026.

  • Free shuttle bus: 4 · In the terminal: 1
  • Free cancellation: 6 of 6
  • Debit card accepted: 5 of 6
  • National
  • Alamo
  • Sixt
  • Enterprise
  • Hertz
  • Avis

Convertible car rental prices in Long Island

  • Ford 7 · from $93
  • Jeep 7 · from $100
  • BMW 5 · from $240
Class Typical cars Suppliers From / day Typical / day
Convertible Ford Mustang Convertible, Jeep Wrangler, BMW 4 Series Convertible 6 $100 $240

The from price is among the lowest prices seen. Half of the offers were cheaper than the typical price. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Nov 2026. Rental companies guarantee the car class, not the exact model. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

Jeep Wrangler rental car in Long Island Hertz

Jeep Wrangler

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 4 bags
  • Automatic transmission
from $100/day
Ford Mustang Convertible rental car in Long Island Enterprise

Ford Mustang Convertible

or similar

  • 4 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $187/day
BMW 4 Series Convertible rental car in Long Island Sixt

BMW 4 Series Convertible

or similar

  • 4 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $240/day

Companies with convertibles in Long Island

Prices and conditions come from searches on TREWL and may have changed. Ratings come from CarTrawler customer reviews, as shown in searches up to Nov 2026. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

National

Free shuttle bus Daily 06:00–23:59 23 min wait Credit and debit cards 2 models
9.3
Excellent 1000+ reviews
from $447/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 9.1 Cleanliness 9.2 Service at the rental desk 9.4 Pick-up process 9.3 Drop-off process 9.5

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Breakdown assistance
  • Airport fee
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Winter tires · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat · Additional driver

Office

National at New York: JFK International Airport
Building 308 Federal Circle, Jamaica, 11430, NY
8446481610

Alamo

In the terminal Daily 06:00–23:59 29 min wait Credit and debit cards 1 model
9.3
Excellent 10000+ reviews
from $254/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.9 Cleanliness 9.5 Service at the rental desk 9.5 Pick-up process 9.5 Drop-off process 9.4

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Glass and tire waiver
  • Airport fee
  • Breakdown assistance
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat · Winter tires

Office

Alamo at New York: JFK International Airport
Building 308 Federal Circle, Jamaica, 11430, NY
8446481611

Sixt

Free shuttle bus Daily 00:00–01:00, 06:00–23:59 22 min wait CDW included Credit and debit cards 2 models
8.7
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $93/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.3 Cleanliness 9.1 Service at the rental desk 8.7 Pick-up process 8.5 Drop-off process 8.9

Included in the price

  • Collision damage waiver (CDW)
  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage on selected cars
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat · GPS

Office

Sixt at New York: JFK International Airport
312 Federal Cir, Jamaica, 11430-1514, NY
+18887498227

Enterprise

22 min wait Credit and debit cards 1 model
8.4
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $187/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.9 Cleanliness 8.4 Service at the rental desk 8.6 Pick-up process 8.3 Drop-off process 8.8

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Office

Enterprise in Hempstead
602 Sunrise Hwy, Rockville Centre, 11570 5129, NY
5168873434

Hertz

Free shuttle bus Daily 00:00–02:00, 06:00–23:59 14 min wait Credit and debit cards 1 model
7.1
Very good 2000+ reviews
from $100/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.5 Cleanliness 6.0 Service at the rental desk 7.2 Pick-up process 7.0 Drop-off process 9.1

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Free tank
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat · Additional driver

Office

Hertz at New York: JFK International Airport
Building 318, Jamaica, Ny, New York City, 11430-9508, NY
7186567600

Avis

Free shuttle bus 9 min wait Credit card only 1 model
6.5
Good 5000+ reviews
from $246/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.8 Cleanliness 6.9 Service at the rental desk 5.6 Pick-up process 5.4 Drop-off process 8.2

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Avis in Jamaica
Building #305 Federal Circle Jfk International Airport, Jamaica, 11430, NY
718-244-5400

Rental conditions in Long Island

Based on 6 suppliers here and nearby. Data from the 12 months to Nov 2026.

Driver age Minimum age 21. Drivers under 25 pay $25 a day extra (Hertz).
Debit card Accepted by 5 of 6 suppliers: National, Alamo, Sixt, Enterprise and Hertz.
Credit card Usually required, in the main driver's name. 1 of 6 suppliers list no debit option.
Mileage Unlimited at all 6 suppliers.
Fuel policy Full to full (4 suppliers), Free tank (1 supplier)
Transmission All cars are automatic.
Electric and hybrid Toyota Prius Hybrid, Kia Niro Electric and Ford Mustang Mach-E, from $97 a day.
Cancellation Free up to 48 hours before pick-up at 6 suppliers.
Insurance included Theft protection (TP) (4 suppliers), Third-party liability (TPL) (4 suppliers), Glass and tire waiver (1 supplier).
Included in the price Airport fee, Taxes, Breakdown assistance
One-way rental Allowed by 4 suppliers. One-way fee seen: $91–$460.
Free additional driver Alamo
Extras GPS (5 suppliers), Infant seat (5 suppliers), Child seat (5 suppliers), Booster seat (5 suppliers), Ski rack (3 suppliers), Winter tires (2 suppliers)
Special offers Pre-registration available (3 suppliers), Free additional driver (1 supplier), Special discount (1 supplier)

Where to pick up in Long Island

Pick-up point Type Cars Suppliers From / day Average wait
New York: JFK International Airport · 18 km Airport 3 6 $93 20 min
New York La Guardia Airport · 22 km Airport 5 6 $127 22 min
Manhattan Midtown West · 31 km City office 3 4 $100 19 min
Woodside · 24 km City office 1 3 $246 21 min
Midtown/times Square · 31 km City office 1 3 $100 19 min
Bronx Woodlawn · 26 km City office 1 2 $104 22 min
Hempstead · 4 km City office 1 1 $187 22 min
New York Manhattan · 30 km City office 1 1 $187 15 min

Convertible car rental near Long Island

Convertible car rental in the USA

Other car types in Long Island

Convertible car rental in Long Island: FAQ

How much does convertible rental cost in Long Island?

Convertible from $100, $258 on average. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Nov 2026.

Which companies offer convertible rental in Long Island?

National, Alamo, Sixt, Enterprise, Hertz and Avis. Hertz is the cheapest, about $118 a day on average. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Nov 2026.

Which models can I get for convertible rental in Long Island?

Most offered: Ford Mustang Convertible, Jeep Wrangler and BMW 4 Series Convertible. Brands: Ford, Jeep and BMW.

What is the minimum age to rent a car in Long Island?

The lowest minimum age among our partners in Long Island is 21. Drivers under 25 pay a young-driver fee of $25 a day.

Can I rent a car in Long Island with a debit card?

5 of 6 companies accept a debit card: National, Alamo, Sixt, Enterprise and Hertz.

Can I return the car somewhere else in Long Island?

3% of searches in Long Island are one-way. Enter a different drop-off location in the search form to see the one-way fee.