Car Rental in Middletown

  • Free cancellation on most offers
  • 24/7 customer service
  • No hidden fees
  • Pay later on many offers
Driver age
Quick filters

Optional. Narrow the search now; you can change or remove these on the results page.

Seats
Options

Cheap car rental in Middletown, USA

We have no fresh offers in Middletown yet. Prices and availability change daily, so search your dates to see today's cars and prices.

Nearest desks with offers

Car rental prices near Middletown by car type

Class Typical cars Suppliers From / day Typical / day
Economy Mitsubishi Mirage, Chevrolet Spark, Kia Rio 10 $50 $98
Compact Nissan Versa, Kia Soul, Kia Niro Electric 12 $57 $99
Intermediate Toyota Corolla, Toyota Prius Hybrid, Hyundai Elantra 12 $62 $112
Standard Volkswagen Jetta, Nissan Altima, Mercedes C Class 11 $54 $96
Full size Chevrolet Malibu, Toyota Camry, Dodge Magnum 11 $61 $107
Small SUV Buick Encore, Jeep Renegade, Audi Q3 9 $68 $113
Medium SUV Toyota Rav4, Jeep Wrangler, Hyundai Santa Fe 12 $67 $116
Large SUV Chevrolet Suburban, Ford Explorer, Ford Expedition 11 $96 $161
SUV Chevrolet Bolt ELECTRIC, Ford Flex 5 $52 $119
Minivan Chrysler Pacifica, Dodge Grand Caravan, Nissan Quest 12 $72 $147
12-passenger van Ford Transit Passengervan, Ford E350, Ford ClubWagon 6 $118 $192
15-passenger van Chevrolet Express, Ford Transit 5 $116 $157
Luxury Audi A4, Chrysler 300, Cadillac CTS 8 $95 $162
Premium Nissan Maxima, Chevrolet Impala, Volkswagen Passat 10 $95 $168
Convertible Ford Mustang Convertible, BMW 4 Series Convertible, Jeep Wrangler 7 $100 $254
Small or medium truck Nissan Frontier, Toyota Tacoma, Ford F-150 8 $79 $106
Large truck Dodge Ram, Chevrolet Silverado, Toyota Tundra 5 $58 $142

The from price is among the lowest prices seen. Half of the offers were cheaper than the typical price. Based on 1,337 offers seen in the 12 months to Nov 2026. Rental companies guarantee the car class, not the exact model. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

Mitsubishi Mirage rental car in Middletown Enterprise

Mitsubishi Mirage

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $50/day
Hyundai Venue rental car in Middletown Budget

Hyundai Venue

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $52/day
Kia Soul rental car in Middletown Avis

Kia Soul

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $57/day
Kia Rio rental car in Middletown Avis

Kia Rio

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $59/day
Nissan Versa rental car in Middletown Alamo

Nissan Versa

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $60/day
Kia Niro Electric rental car in Middletown Budget

Kia Niro Electric

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $60/day
Chevrolet Spark rental car in Middletown Hertz

Chevrolet Spark

or similar

  • 4 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $63/day
Hyundai Accent rental car in Middletown Payless

Hyundai Accent

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $64/day

Car rental companies near Middletown

Prices and conditions come from searches on TREWL and may have changed. Ratings come from CarTrawler customer reviews, as shown in searches up to Nov 2026. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

Sixt

In the terminal 27 min wait Credit and debit cards
9.4
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $78/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.9 Cleanliness 9.7 Service at the rental desk 9.5 Pick-up process 9.4 Drop-off process 9.9

Included in the price

  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage on selected cars
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available
  • Taxes and fees included in the price: about 41% of the base rate
  • Pay at the desk or prepay online

Extras (paid at the desk)

Child seat from $17 a day

Office

Sixt at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Road Terminal A, Newark, 07114, NJ
+18887498227

National

In the terminal 23 min wait Credit and debit cards
8.9
Excellent 1000+ reviews
from $117/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.6 Cleanliness 8.8 Service at the rental desk 9.1 Pick-up process 8.8 Drop-off process 9.2

Included in the price

  • Breakdown assistance

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Taxes and fees included in the price: about 46% of the base rate
  • Pay at the desk or prepay online

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS from $11 a day · Winter tires from $7 a day · Ski rack from $7 a day · Child seat from $6 a day

Office

National at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Rd, Newark, 07114, NJ
8447272983

Alamo

In the terminal 24 min wait Credit and debit cards
8.9
Excellent 10000+ reviews
from $111/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.7 Cleanliness 9.1 Service at the rental desk 8.8 Pick-up process 9.2 Drop-off process 8.9

Included in the price

  • Airport fee
  • Breakdown assistance

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available
  • Taxes and fees included in the price: about 47% of the base rate
  • Pay at the desk or prepay online

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS from $11 a day · Ski rack from $7 a day · Child seat from $6 a day · Winter tires from $7 a day

Office

Alamo at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Rd, Newark, 07114, NJ
8447272984

Enterprise

21 min wait Credit card only
8.4
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $62/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.0 Cleanliness 8.4 Service at the rental desk 8.6 Pick-up process 8.3 Drop-off process 8.9

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Office

Red Bank
41 Newman Springs Rd, Shrewsbury, 07702, NJ
7325768881

Thrifty

Free shuttle bus 16 min wait Credit and debit cards
8.2
Excellent 5000+ reviews
from $109/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.9 Cleanliness 8.5 Service at the rental desk 8.0 Pick-up process 7.9 Drop-off process 8.8

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Airport fee
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available
  • Prepay only

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS from $16 a day · Ski rack from $18 a day · Child seat from $13 a day · Snow chains · Additional driver

Office

Thrifty at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Road, Airtrain P2, Newark, NJ, United States, 07114
(973) 824-2003

Dollar

Free shuttle bus 16 min wait Credit and debit cards
7.8
Very good 5000+ reviews
from $118/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.5 Cleanliness 8.3 Service at the rental desk 7.3 Pick-up process 7.2 Drop-off process 8.8

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Breakdown assistance
  • Airport fee
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available
  • Prepay only

Extras (paid at the desk)

Ski rack from $18 a day · Child seat from $13 a day · GPS from $16 a day · Additional driver

Office

Dollar at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Road, Airtrain P2, Newark, NJ, United States, 07114
(973) 824-2003

Hertz

In the terminal 16 min wait Credit and debit cards
7.4
Very good 2000+ reviews
from $94/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.5 Cleanliness 7.8 Service at the rental desk 7.2 Pick-up process 7.1 Drop-off process 7.5

Included in the price

  • Airport fee
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed
  • Pre-registration available
  • Taxes and fees included in the price: about 0% of the base rate
  • Prepay only

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS from $16 a day · Ski rack from $18 a day · Child seat from $13 a day · Additional driver

Office

Hertz at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Rd, Newark, Nj, 07114, NJ
9736212000

Avis

18 min wait Credit card only
7.1
Very good 5000+ reviews
from $58/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.8 Cleanliness 6.9 Service at the rental desk 7.2 Pick-up process 6.8 Drop-off process 8.2

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Avis in Red Bank Downtown
25 Pearl St (cnr of Water (Rt 35) & Pearl), Red Bank, 07701, NJ
732-747-0308

Budget

15 min wait Credit card only
6.8
Good 10000+ reviews
from $48/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.5 Cleanliness 7.0 Service at the rental desk 6.8 Pick-up process 6.1 Drop-off process 8.0

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Budget in Manasquan
224 Hawthorne Ave (aka Rt 35N), Point Pleasant Beach, 08742, NJ
732-892-0909

Payless

Free shuttle bus 20 min wait Credit card only
6.2
Good 1000+ reviews
from $71/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 5.6 Cleanliness 6.4 Service at the rental desk 5.9 Pick-up process 5.5 Drop-off process 7.7

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Cancellation fee $130

Office

Payless at Newark International Airport New Jersey
134 Lindbergh Rd, Newark Liberty Intl Airport, Newark, 07114, NJ
973-242-2124

Ace

4 min wait Credit card only
5.4
Average 2000+ reviews
from $111/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 4.5 Cleanliness 7.1 Service at the rental desk 5.8 Pick-up process 4.6 Drop-off process 5.3

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Office

Ace at Newark International Airport New Jersey
Newark, New Jersey(NJ), United States of America, 07114

Flizzr

In the terminal 12 min wait Credit card only
9.1
Few reviews 5+ reviews
from $102/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.4 Cleanliness 9.4 Service at the rental desk 9.2 Pick-up process 9.1 Drop-off process 9.4

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • One-way rental allowed

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Flizzr at Newark International Airport New Jersey
132 Carson Road Terminal A, Newark, 07114, NJ
+1-8887498227

Rental conditions in Middletown

Based on 12 suppliers here and nearby. Data from the 12 months to Nov 2026.

Debit card Accepted by 6 of 12 suppliers: Sixt, National, Alamo, Thrifty, Dollar and Hertz.
Credit card Usually required, in the main driver's name. 6 of 12 suppliers list no debit option.
Mileage Unlimited at all 12 suppliers.
Fuel policy Full to full (8 suppliers)
Transmission Automatic 99%, manual 1%.
Electric and hybrid Chevrolet Bolt ELECTRIC and Toyota Prius Hybrid, from $84 a day.
Cancellation Free up to 48 hours before pick-up at 11 suppliers. Cancellation fee: Payless $130.
Insurance included Theft protection (TP) (3 suppliers), Third-party liability (TPL) (2 suppliers).
Included in the price Taxes, Airport fee, Breakdown assistance
One-way rental Allowed by 4 suppliers. One-way fee seen: $79–$475.
Extras Infant seat (9 suppliers), Child seat (9 suppliers), Booster seat (9 suppliers), GPS (8 suppliers), Ski rack (5 suppliers), Winter tires (2 suppliers)
Special offers Pre-registration available (5 suppliers), Special discount (1 supplier)
Taxes and fees Included in the price: 0%–47% of the base rate, depending on the supplier.
Extras per day Child seat from $6 · Additional driver from $18 · GPS from $11 · Ski rack from $7
Payment Pay at the desk possible at 3 of 6 suppliers. Prepay only at 3 of 6 suppliers.

Driving in the USA: drive on the right · 0.08% blood alcohol (0.05% in Utah) · 0.02% for new drivers. Driving rules

Where to pick up

Pick-up point Type Suppliers From / day Average wait
Red Bank Downtown · 6 km City office 1 $58 18 min
Red Bank · 7 km City office 1 $62 21 min
Staten Island Charleston · 18 km City office 1 $72 21 min
Brooklyn 4th Ave · 26 km City office 1 $72 24 min
Brooklyn Greenwood · 29 km City office 1 $85 24 min
Manasquan · 32 km City office 2 $48 17 min
Newark International Airport New Jersey · 33 km Airport 12 $71 18 min
Lakewood Hle · 35 km City office 4 $44 18 min
Cranbury · 35 km City office 1 $65 18 min
Jersey City 455 Washington Blvd · 37 km City office 2 $68 19 min
Show all 21
Pick-up point Type Suppliers From / day Average wait
New York: JFK International Airport · 39 km Airport 11 $45 18 min
East Windsor · 40 km City office 1 $65 18 min
Midtown/times Square · 42 km City office 3 $79 19 min
Jamaica · 42 km City office 3 $75 10 min
Manhattan Midtown West · 43 km City office 6 $49 16 min
Woodside · 43 km City office 4 $75 20 min
New York Manhattan · 44 km City office 3 $119 15 min
Manhattan Upper West Side · 45 km City office 4 $58 18 min
New York La Guardia Airport · 46 km Airport 11 $58 20 min
Princeton Larrys Sunoco · 47 km City office 1 $65 14 min
Toms River Downtown · 49 km City office 1 $51 21 min

Near Middletown

Car rental in Middletown: what to expect

Customers report an average wait at the desk from 4 min at Ace to 27 min at Sixt.

For a small car, Enterprise is the cheapest at about $46 a day and is rated 8.4 out of 10. Sixt is rated 9.4 and costs about $77.

99% of the cars offered here are automatic. Mileage is unlimited at all 12 suppliers. Most suppliers allow free cancellation up to 48 hours before pick-up.

Car rental in Middletown: FAQ

Where do I pick up my rental car in Middletown?

It depends on the rental company, and the pick-up type is shown for each company on this page. Your booking confirmation always includes the exact pick-up address and instructions.

Can I pick up a car in Middletown and return it somewhere else?

Yes, one-way rentals are possible with many companies, but they usually charge a one-way fee, which is higher for longer distances or for drop-offs in another country. Enter a different drop-off location in the search form to see one-way prices with the fee included.

What is the minimum age to rent a car in Middletown?

The minimum age to rent a car in Middletown is usually 21, although some companies accept drivers from 18 and others require 23 or 25 for larger or premium cars. Drivers under 25 usually pay a daily young driver fee, and some companies limit younger drivers to smaller car classes. You also need to have held your driving license for at least one year.

Can I rent a car in Middletown with a debit card?

Rental companies in Middletown typically accept major credit cards such as Visa, Mastercard and American Express. The card must be in the main driver's name and have enough funds for the security deposit. Debit and prepaid cards are accepted only by some companies, sometimes with a higher deposit or extra checks. The accepted cards are listed for each company on this page.

What fuel policy do rental companies use in Middletown?

The fuel policy is shown for each company on this page. The most common ones in Middletown are:
  • Full to full: you get the car with a full tank and return it full. This is usually the cheapest option because you only pay for the fuel you use at pump prices. Refuel near the drop-off point, or the company will charge for the missing fuel plus a service fee.
  • Same to same: you return the car with the same fuel level as at pick-up.

Rent a van, SUV or luxury car near Middletown