Car Rental in New York Amherst

  • Free cancellation on most offers
  • 24/7 customer service
  • No hidden fees
  • Pay later on many offers
Driver age
Quick filters

Optional. Narrow the search now; you can change or remove these on the results page.

Seats
Options
  • 8rental companies
  • from $60 per day
  • 9.2 top rated · National

A rental car here costs $136 a day on average, about $956 for a week. Thrifty is the cheapest for a small car, about $60 a day. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026.

  • In the terminal: 4
  • Free cancellation: 8 of 8
  • Debit card accepted: 2 of 8
  • National
  • Alamo
  • Enterprise
  • Budget
  • Dollar
  • Hertz
  • +2

Car rental prices in New York Amherst by car type

Class Typical cars Suppliers From / day
Economy Chevrolet Spark, Kia Rio 3 $60
Compact Ford Focus, Kia Niro Electric, Kia Soul 3 $60
Intermediate Toyota Corolla, Toyota Prius Hybrid 2 $111
Standard Volkswagen Jetta, Nissan Altima 3 $90
Full size Chevrolet Malibu, Toyota Camry 2 $90
Small SUV Buick Encore 1 $122
Medium SUV Chevrolet Equinox, Ford Edge, Ford Escape 3 $96
Large SUV Ford Explorer, Ford Expedition, Nissan Pathfinder 3 $159
Minivan Chrysler Pacifica, Nissan Quest 2 $138
12-passenger van Ford Transit Passengervan 1 $268
Convertible Jeep Wrangler 1 $142
Small or medium truck Toyota Tacoma 1 $134

Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026. Rental companies guarantee the car class, not the exact model. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

Chevrolet Spark rental car in New York Amherst Thrifty

Chevrolet Spark

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $60/day
Ford Focus rental car in New York Amherst Thrifty

Ford Focus

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $60/day
Kia Rio rental car in New York Amherst Avis

Kia Rio

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 2 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $107/day
Kia Niro Electric rental car in New York Amherst Avis

Kia Niro Electric

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $119/day
Nissan Versa rental car in New York Amherst Hertz

Nissan Versa

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $120/day
Kia Soul rental car in New York Amherst Avis

Kia Soul

or similar

  • 5 seats
  • 3 bags
  • Automatic transmission
  • Air conditioning
from $123/day

Car rental companies in New York Amherst

Prices and conditions come from searches on TREWL and may have changed. Ratings come from CarTrawler customer reviews, as shown in searches up to Aug 2026. Live availability and prices are shown in search results. How we collect prices

National

In the terminal Mon–Fri 06:00–23:59 · Sat–Sun 06:00–23:00 24 min wait Credit card only
9.2
Excellent 1000+ reviews
from $63/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 9.0 Cleanliness 9.2 Service at the rental desk 9.3 Pick-up process 9.2 Drop-off process 9.4

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee
  • Breakdown assistance

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Winter tires · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

National at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee St, Buffalo, 14225, NY
8338135271

Alamo

In the terminal Mon–Fri 06:00–23:59 · Sat–Sun 06:00–23:00 23 min wait Credit card only
9.1
Excellent 5000+ reviews
from $62/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.9 Cleanliness 9.2 Service at the rental desk 9.2 Pick-up process 9.1 Drop-off process 9.4

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Glass and tire waiver
  • Airport fee
  • Taxes
  • Breakdown assistance

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Free additional driver
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat · Winter tires

Office

Alamo at Niagara Falls International Airport
2035 Niagara Falls Blvd, Niagara Falls, 14304, NY
7162981000

Enterprise

In the terminal Mon–Fri 06:00–23:59 · Sat–Sun 06:00–23:00 21 min wait CDW included Credit card only
9.0
Excellent 2000+ reviews
from $62/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.7 Cleanliness 9.0 Service at the rental desk 9.2 Pick-up process 9.0 Drop-off process 9.3

Included in the price

  • Collision damage waiver (CDW)
  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Enterprise at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee St, Buffalo, 14225, NY
8338135266

Budget

In the terminal Daily 00:00–01:00, 06:30–23:59 16 min wait Credit card only
8.7
Excellent 10000+ reviews
from $46/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 8.1 Cleanliness 8.5 Service at the rental desk 9.0 Pick-up process 8.5 Drop-off process 9.4

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Glass and tire waiver
  • Airport fee

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage on selected cars
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Budget at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee St, Buffalo, 14225, NY
716-632-6400

Dollar

Daily 06:00–23:59 15 min wait Credit and debit cards
8.2
Excellent 5000+ reviews
from $47/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 7.9 Cleanliness 8.5 Service at the rental desk 8.1 Pick-up process 7.9 Drop-off process 8.8

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee
  • Breakdown assistance
  • Taxes

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Dollar at Buffalo Airport
4200 Genesee Street, Buffalo, NY, United States, 14225
(866) 434-2226

Hertz

14 min wait Credit and debit cards
7.3
Very good 2000+ reviews
from $120/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.9 Cleanliness 7.7 Service at the rental desk 7.2 Pick-up process 6.7 Drop-off process 8.2

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Airport fee

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Hertz in New York Amherst
3780 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, Ny, 14226, NY
7168360764

Avis

18 min wait Credit card only
7.1
Very good 5000+ reviews
from $111/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.8 Cleanliness 6.9 Service at the rental desk 7.2 Pick-up process 6.8 Drop-off process 8.2

Included in the price

  • Theft protection (TP)
  • Third-party liability (TPL)
  • Glass and tire waiver
  • Airport fee

Policies

  • Full to full
  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Avis in New York Amherst
3740 Sheridan Dr, Amherst, 14226, NY
716-831-8041

Thrifty

16 min wait Credit card only
6.7
Good 5000+ reviews
from $60/day
Ratings, policies and office

Customer ratings

Value for money 6.2 Cleanliness 7.4 Service at the rental desk 6.3 Pick-up process 6.0 Drop-off process 7.8

Included in the price

  • Taxes

Policies

  • Unlimited mileage
  • Free cancellation up to 48 h before pick-up
  • Pre-registration available

Extras (paid at the desk)

GPS · Ski rack · Infant seat · Child seat · Booster seat

Office

Thrifty in New York Amherst
3780 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, NY, United States, 14226
(716) 836-0764

Rental conditions in New York Amherst

Based on 8 suppliers here and nearby. Data from the 12 months to Aug 2026.

Debit card Accepted by 2 of 8 suppliers: Dollar and Hertz.
Credit card Usually required, in the main driver's name. 6 of 8 suppliers list no debit option.
Mileage Unlimited at all 8 suppliers.
Fuel policy Full to full (5 suppliers)
Transmission All cars are automatic.
Electric and hybrid Kia Niro Electric, Toyota Prius Hybrid and Ford Mustang Mach-E, from $104 a day.
Cancellation Free up to 48 hours before pick-up at 8 suppliers.
Insurance included Theft protection (TP) (7 suppliers), Third-party liability (TPL) (7 suppliers), Glass and tire waiver (3 suppliers).
Included in the price Airport fee, Breakdown assistance, Taxes
Free additional driver Alamo
Extras GPS (8 suppliers), Infant seat (8 suppliers), Child seat (8 suppliers), Booster seat (8 suppliers), Ski rack (5 suppliers), Winter tires (2 suppliers)
Special offers Pre-registration available (4 suppliers), Free additional driver (1 supplier), Special discount (1 supplier)

Driving in the USA: drive on the right · 0.08% blood alcohol (0.05% in Utah) · 0.02% for new drivers. Driving rules

Car rental in New York Amherst: what to expect

3 suppliers have their desk at 3780 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, Ny, 14226, NY. Customers report an average wait at the desk from 14 min at Hertz to 18 min at Avis.

For a small car, Dollar is the cheapest at about $55 a day and is rated 8.2 out of 10. National is rated 9.2 and costs about $63.

100% of the cars offered here are automatic. Mileage is unlimited at all 8 suppliers. Most suppliers allow free cancellation up to 48 hours before pick-up.

Car rental in New York Amherst: FAQ

How much does it cost to rent a car in New York Amherst?

Car rental in New York Amherst starts from $60 per day, and the average price is $136 per day. Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026. At the average daily rate, a rental costs about $409 for a 3-day weekend and $956 for a week. Rentals of a month or longer usually get a lower daily rate. The final price depends on the season, the car class, the rental company and how early you book.

Which car rental company has the best reviews in New York Amherst?

According to customer reviews, the highest-rated car rental companies in New York Amherst are:
  • Hertz: rated 7.3/10 by 2000+ customers, average price $138 per day
  • Avis: rated 7.1/10 by 5000+ customers, average price $153 per day
  • Thrifty: rated 6.7/10 by 5000+ customers
Ratings cover value for money, car cleanliness, desk service, and the pick-up and drop-off process. Ratings come from CarTrawler customer reviews, as shown in searches up to Aug 2026.

Which is the cheapest car rental company in New York Amherst?

By the average daily price of a small car (mini, economy or compact), the cheapest rental companies in New York Amherst are:
  • Thrifty: about $60 per day
  • Hertz: about $113 per day
  • Avis: about $116 per day
Based on offers seen in the 12 months to Aug 2026. For the lowest price, book early, choose a smaller car and check the fuel policy and deposit before you pay.

Where do I pick up my rental car in New York Amherst?

It depends on the rental company, and the pick-up type is shown for each company on this page. Your booking confirmation always includes the exact pick-up address and instructions.

Can I pick up a car in New York Amherst and return it somewhere else?

Yes, one-way rentals are possible with many companies, but they usually charge a one-way fee, which is higher for longer distances or for drop-offs in another country. Enter a different drop-off location in the search form to see one-way prices with the fee included.

What is the minimum age to rent a car in New York Amherst?

The minimum age to rent a car in New York Amherst is usually 21, although some companies accept drivers from 18 and others require 23 or 25 for larger or premium cars. Drivers under 25 usually pay a daily young driver fee, and some companies limit younger drivers to smaller car classes. You also need to have held your driving license for at least one year.

Can I rent a car in New York Amherst with a debit card?

Rental companies in New York Amherst typically accept major credit cards such as Visa, Mastercard and American Express. The card must be in the main driver's name and have enough funds for the security deposit. Debit and prepaid cards are accepted only by some companies, sometimes with a higher deposit or extra checks. Companies that accept debit cards in New York Amherst: Hertz. The accepted cards are listed for each company on this page.

Which car rental companies in New York Amherst offer unlimited mileage?

Hertz, Avis and Thrifty include unlimited mileage on all cars in New York Amherst. The mileage policy is shown in each offer before you book. With limited mileage, every kilometer or mile over the daily allowance is charged extra.

What fuel policy do rental companies use in New York Amherst?

The fuel policy is shown for each company on this page. The most common ones in New York Amherst are:
  • Full to full: you get the car with a full tank and return it full. This is usually the cheapest option because you only pay for the fuel you use at pump prices. Refuel near the drop-off point, or the company will charge for the missing fuel plus a service fee. Offered by Avis.
  • Same to same: you return the car with the same fuel level as at pick-up.

Can I rent an electric or hybrid car in New York Amherst?

Yes. Companies offering electric and hybrid cars in New York Amherst include Avis. The cheapest is Avis, from $111 per day. Hybrids need no charging. With a fully electric car, check the charging options along your route and the company's charging policy before you set off.

Rent a van, SUV or luxury car near New York Amherst